Kasese High Court Dismisses an Election Petition Filed by Jackson Mbaju Against David Mulindwa Isimbwa

BY MATHIUS KAHUNGU

The Kasese High Court has dismissed an election petition filed by National Unity Platform’s Jackson Mbaju commonly known as Kathika and upheld the election of David Mulindwa Isimbwa (NRM) as the duly elected Member of Parliament for Busongora County South.  

The petition arose from the parliamentary election for directly elected Member of Parliament for Busongora County South that was held on January 15, 2026.

On January 17, 2026, the Kasese District Returning Officer, Mr. Godfrey Mbabazi declared David Mulindwa Isimbwa as the duly elected Member of Parliament for Busongora County South in Kasese District having obtained the highest number of total votes cast.

According to the Returning Officer, the election attracted seven candidates and David Mulindwa Isimbwa obtained the majority vote amounting to 10,845 while Jackson Mbaju, the petitioner received 10,760 votes, losing with a margin of 85 votes. 

Other candidates included Gideon Thembo Mujungu with 4,262 votes, Aloysius Baguma Kighema with 3845 votes, Juma Munezero with 1,145 votes, Sedrack Mbaju Bakulirahi Arinaitwe with 322 votes and Frank Asiimwe Barozi with 232 votes.

Jackson Mbaju was not satisfied with the results and sought a vote recount before the Kasese Chief Magistrate’s Court. However, despite being granted, the process didn’t proceed because the ballot box seals were found having been tampered with, leading to dismissal of the application.

Mbaju then petitioned the High Court seeking to overturn the results and instead be declared the winner, citing alteration and inflation of results.

More

According to him, the results from Jabezi primary compound A-K polling station found in Kyakitale Ward in Katwe Kabatooro Town council were allegedly inaccurately reflected in the constituency tally.

Mbaju contested that he obtained 25 votes at the said polling station and the 1st respondent got 173 votes but however, the official results relied upon by the electoral commission reported that the petitioner obtained 0 votes and the 1st respondent got 398 votes.

Mbaju maintained that had the votes at Jabezi primary school compound A-K been corrected and incorporated in the final tally sheet, his total votes would rise from 10,760 to 10,785 while the 1st  respondent’s total vote  would have decreased from 10,845 to 10, 620 votes and he would have accordingly obtained 165 more votes than the 1st respondent, a basis he prayed court to instead subsequently declare him.

He was also seeking court to alternatively set aside the election and order for fresh elections.

However, the 1st respondent, David Mulindwa Isimbwa disputed the petitioner’s account and maintained that the figures recorded in the official constituency tally accurately reflected the results at Jabezi primary school compound A-K polling station and the 1st respondent was lawfully declared after getting the highest number of votes in the constituency.

In a judgment delivered by Her Worship Harriet Atim Okello, the Kasese Chief Magistrate who was holding brief (standing in) for the hearing Judge, Hon. Lady Justice Joanita Gertrude Bushara, dismissed the petition without costs.

 The Judge held that the petitioner did not provide sufficient evidence that would circumstantially compel the constituency tally to be corrected.

The Judge also indicated that the election was held in compliance with the Parliamentary Elections Act among others.

Hon. David Mulindwa Isimbwa welcomed the Judgement and insisted that his election was the exact will of the people of Busongora County South.

He pledged that he would prioritize service delivery of his electorate regardless of their status and political affiliations.

Meanwhile, Jackson Mbaju Kathika, the petitioner told the press that he was not satisfied with the court verdict and would accordingly appeal.

Frank Asiimwe Barozi and Bryans Basisa described the judgement as unfair and a sign of deteriorating Justice.

ENDS

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *